Theo's Midtown

Discover Theo's Midtown Pizza in Jefferson City, MO for delicious gyros, calzones, flavorful appetizers, and Greek-inspired dishes. Enjoy friendly service, a lively bar, and great conversation at 620 W McCarty St. Call +1 573-893-6969 for reservations!

MenuContact

Welcome to Theo's Midtown

Signature Dining Experience

Theo's Midtown
Theo's Midtown
Theo's Midtown
Theo's Midtown

Located at 620 W McCarty St, Jefferson City, MO, Theo's Midtown welcomes diners into a lively atmosphere where flavors intertwine and conversations flourish. This pizzeria serves up a delightful blend of Greek and Italian influences, making it a favorite among locals. The aroma of freshly baked pizzas and savory gyros fills the air, inviting food lovers to explore a menu packed with delicious options. Guests rave about the warm service and vibrant environment, perfect for enjoying a meal with friends or family.

Whether one craves a hearty calzone or a refreshing salad, every dish is crafted to satisfy.

Theo's Midtown stands out in a city rich with dining options, offering a unique culinary experience that reflects the flavor palette of the Mediterranean, punctuated with rustic Italian charm. On Fridays at 6 PM, the restaurant reaches 100% capacity, showing just how much the community values this gem. Here, food isn't just fuel; it's a celebration of friendship and shared moments.

Location & Contact

Address

620 W McCarty St, Jefferson City, MO 65109, United States

Phone

+1 573-893-6969

Social Media

About

Theo's Midtown
Theo's Midtown
Theo's Midtown
Theo's Midtown

Nestled in Jefferson City, Theo's Midtown enjoys a favorable reputation among both locals and visitors. This pizza restaurant combines the vibrant essence of Mediterranean cuisine with the comforting feel of a traditional pizzeria. Open for lunch and dinner, it offers flexible dining opportunities for everyone, whether on break from work or enjoying a casual night out with friends.

One aspect that attracts many is the commitment to serving high-quality dishes that reflect a passion for culinary art. With a solid premise of choosing fresh ingredients, Theo's Midtown ensures flavor is never compromised. The menu provides a taste of Greece through beloved foods such as gyros and meatballs, alongside classic American favorites like mozzarella sticks and specialty pizzas.

Community spirit permeates the establishment; it's not just the food that draws patrons but the atmosphere of warmth and camaraderie. Customers often cite the helpful staff and friendly service, which add to the overall dining experience. By creating this welcoming environment, Theo's Midtown fosters relationships among diners. Many patrons return regularly, not just for a great meal but also to see friendly faces and engage in lively conversations that can last well into the evening.

Regular events, promotions, and themed nights highlight the restaurant's commitment to community engagement, bringing people together over shared meals. By prioritizing quality food and community connection, Theo's Midtown secures its place as a favored dining location in Jefferson City. The restaurant blends culinary expertise with the charm of local dining, establishing itself as a beloved staple in the heart of the city.

Work Hours

  • SundayClosed
  • Monday11 AM-9 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-9 PM
  • Friday11 AM-9 PM
  • Saturday3-9 PM

Theo's Midtown boasts an array of offerings that cater to diverse appetites and occasions. The menu features two broad categories that showcase the culinary expertise behind the counter: mezze, with items like Mozzarella Sticks and Aegean Plate, and hearty sandwiches, including the Cali and Greek Meatball Grinder. Each dish carries an average price of $8 to $7.50, making it affordable to visit regularly.

Popular choices on the gyros menu include the Gyro Midtown and Gyro Sandwich, priced around $10.50, bringing a taste of Greece to Missouri.

Specialty pizzas stand out with unique twists, like the Hellas and The Fredo, available for $16. Guests can also enjoy an a la carte option of these signature pizzas, ensuring a fulfilling experience that celebrates flavors and satisfaction. The restaurant emphasizes fresh ingredients and authentic recipes, ensuring each dish is crafted with care. The combination of a vibrant bar, friendly staff, and a bustling atmosphere transforms a simple meal into an enjoyable outing.

Theo's Midtown

The exterior of Theo's Midtown features a welcoming vibe, reflecting the rich color palette reminiscent of Mediterranean landscapes. The location is easy to find on W McCarty St, with a casual façade inviting diners to step inside and enjoy a meal. Outdoor seating offers guests a chance to savor the delicious flavors al fresco, perfect for warm Missouri evenings.

Inside, the restaurant buzzes with activity, creating an ambiance where laughter and hearty discussions thrive. It embodies a blend of casual and festive, ideal for date nights, family outings, or celebratory gatherings. The overall vibe feels like a neighborhood gathering spot where everyone feels at home, making it easier for patrons to unwind and enjoy their time.

Customer Reviews

I can't even explain how good this place is! We had a make your own pizza, meatball appetizer and a cheese filled breadstick. We are from NY and this might be one of the best pizzas we've ever tasted!! Meatballs were season perfectly and the breadsticks were so tender and delicious. Thank you for an amazing meal!!

T
T_RocNY37 0.

We are locals and we love this restaurant. Best pizza in town in our opinion. Greek style. Sandwiches are also great, and I am not a huge sandwich fan. Theirs is flavorful and fresh. Gyros are another favorite of ours. Try the Agean Plate appetizer, comes with the most amazing pita chips. You'll be hooked! Place is always clean, nice full bar, staff is welcoming. They get busy, and there's a good reason for that. Not cheapest place in town, but well worth it. Try them! Eat local!

D
Debbi H.

We ate an early dinner on Saturday. Our server was wonderful and attentive. We enjoyed the Theo's special pizza with Greek sauage, and mushrooms. The House salad was very tasty. Penna with Maranara sauce was delicious. We will be back!

H
H. B.

First time visiting based upon son's recommendation. He takes after me, so he has excellent taste :). Absolutely great meal and lovely waitress, Maddie (make sure to ask her about how the pizzas are cooked, she provides in depth info!). Started with Pesto Chips which were delicious! Got a half Brooklyn, half Niki pizza. Both flavors were outstanding! Try it, you'll love it.

G
Geoff S.

One of Jefferson City's best restaurants by far! The pizzas are exceptions but the Greek menu is where this place really shines. The Gyro is out of this world and they use a house feta cheese that is the best flavor and consistency wise. The star of the restaurant to my family is the Greek fries. I know what you're thinking Greek fries, what can make those special? Well let me tell you. They are seasoned with Greek seasoning then covered in a feta based Queso, topped with more feta, pickled onions then covered in Greek chicken, my family likes to add Gyro meat. The best of the best when you add a side of their house made tzatziki sauce. This place is the best, you have to try it. The full bar and extensive menu makes it the best for not only dinners but also date nite and even family dinner! Trust me on the Greek fries, get them and a gyro and never look back!

B
Brian J.

My wife and I decided to have an early dinner seeking Greek food. On the drive to Theo's, she read a review about a customer who enjoyed the food but had taken offense to the neon RAAAI-DERRRS sign above the bar. I had to drive faster to get there to see that sign in all its glory. Great food, great atmosphere, great taste in football teams. But there is a matter of that Chiefs helmet on the wall...

S
Stacey R.